The winning BI-SU ad (#340) is fatiguing after a month at the top, so the meeting builds its successor by going deeper into the narrative that actually won — rarity and luxury, not science. The audience data is unusually clean: women 35–45, Instagram Feed + Stories, 9:16, iPhone, 42 conversions — profiled as a well-off ~43-year-old who is skeptical of scientific claims and buys to feel like a discerning collector, comfortable at $100–400+ on premium skincare. Three new angles get built to replace #340: Rarity Index (vs saffron, diamonds, royal jelly), Price Comparison (gram-for-gram vs silver and gold) and Scarcity (limited "harvest drops", mirroring the brand's Japanese playbook). Visuals move from "20s lifestyle" to a Vogue-magazine aesthetic — older, more diverse avatars, luxury interiors instead of subways — plus luxury unboxing UGC and Kyoto / Ginza store brand-story ads for credibility. Second priority: BC16 is selling after its LP tweak → ship more BC16 ads immediately with the same luxury/scarcity angles and ice-themed summer visuals.
Decisions
- Pivot the narrative from scientific proof to rarity + exclusivity. The data says the 35–45 buyer discounts scientific claims and responds to the "rarest beauty ingredient" framing — so deepen that story instead of arguing efficacy.
- Build three named angles to succeed #340 (it's fatiguing, don't wait for it to die):
- Upgrade the visual system to "sophisticated luxury". Retire the 20s-lifestyle look: older, more diverse avatars (Asian, 35–45) and high-end settings (modern apartments, luxury stores) instead of generic ones (subways).
- Format split: Kim ships many AI image variations for rapid testing; Han ships branded motion-graphic videos reusing existing AI assets to save time; plus luxury unboxing UGC and brand-story ads shot around the Kyoto + Ginza stores to build trust.
- Prioritise BC16 now. It's selling well after a recent landing-page tweak → create more BC16 ads immediately to ride the momentum and feed the algorithm data; apply the luxury/scarcity angles with ice-themed summer visuals, and build a BC16 landing page for the AI lane.
- Concepts get shared for approval before production (Han) — no more full builds off an unreviewed idea.
Action items — tick when done
▶ Fathom recording